Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie is the perfect no bake dessert for any time of year!

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie-Hero


I absolutely can’t believe that the month of August is almost over. Where did this summer go? Where did this MONTH go? Did you know that during the month of August there were several days devoted to pies? National Lemon Meringue Pie Day was Aug 15;  National Ice Cream Pie Day was Aug 18;  National Chocolate Pecan Pie Day was Aug 20; and National Peach Pie Day was Aug 24. I know that this is a few days late but I’m going to share with you a simple recipe for Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie. This was my first time making it but it definitely won’t be my last!

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie-content1


Oreo Pie Crust

1/2 Gallon Vanilla Ice Cream

Whipped Topping (not Whipped Cream)

1 Bag of Mini Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut  Butter Topping

5-7 Chocolate Oreos

Step One: Grind up 3/4 bag of mini peanut butter cups and chocolate oreos in food processor until crumbly. This will be your filling.

Step Two: Spread 1/4 gallon of thawed vanilla ice cream into bottom of oreo pie crust.

Step Three: Spread an even layer of peanut butter cup and oreo filling from step one right on top of vanilla ice cream.

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie-filling

Step Four: Spread remaining 1/4 gallon of thawed vanilla ice cream right on top of filling. Cover and put in freezer until firm. This will probably take a few hours.

Step Five: Before eating, spread whipped topping on top of pie and finish with cut up peanut butter cups. Drizzle with peanut butter topping (optional).

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie-feature

It was so delicious and it was a big hit with my family. My girls could not wait to get their hands on it!

Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie-content2


I’m giving away a $100 gift card to (the wonderful company who sponsored this post.) to ONE lucky reader.

US Residents only

TO ENTER: Leave a comment telling me what your favorite kind of pie is. If you have the recipe for it, leave a link to that below too!

Winner will be notified by September 5.

Good luck!



Similar Posts


  1. Banana Cream Pie is by far my favorite pie out there! I have never made it myself because I am still blessed to have my grandmother close to us and she makes it for me on special occasions!! Love it!

  2. Boy, that’s a tough one one (between apple, pumpkin, and pecan), but after giving some thought to it, I’ll go with pecan pie being my favorite! Your peanut butter pie looks delicious, and I’m going to try it! Thanks for a great giveaway!

  3. Adrienne Gordon says:

    I like apple pie

  4. Margaret Smith says:

    I love a dutch apple pie.
    Your Peanut Butter ice cream Cup pie sounds so delicious.

  5. My favorite kind of pie is banana cream,no recipe though.

  6. My favorite kind of pie is Chocolate Pecan Pie.

  7. My favorite pie is chocolate!

  8. Sue Barney says:

    My favorite pie is banana cream but my mother still makes them for me so I dont have her recipe yet.

  9. Melissa C says:

    Pumpkin pie is my favorite!

  10. Danielle Marie says:

    i really love boysenberry pie. it has always been my favorite.

  11. Tari Lawson says:

    I love cherry pie, made with fresh sour peaches.

  12. Cynthia C says:

    My favorite pie is Coconut Cream.

  13. Cheyenne W says:

    I love a Snickers pie.

  14. melissa Resnick says:

    i love love love bannana cream pie

  15. mickeyfan says:

    In the spring, it’s strawberry. Summer’s #1 is peach. Fall…tossup between pumpkin and caramel dutch apple.

  16. Debbi Wellenstein says:

    I love apple pie-I don’t use a recipe!

  17. Richard Hicks says:

    My favorite pie would be blackberry!

  18. Meghan Malicoat says:

    I love a good pecan pie. I only get it maybe once a year.

  19. Tracie Cooper says:

    My favorite is chocolate chip pecan pie!

  20. Susan Chester says:

    I love blackberry pie with vanilla ice cream!

  21. Cherry pie warmed up with vanilla ice cream! Ahh now I’m craving it!

  22. Crystal F says:

    My favorite pie is pecan pie. Thank you!!

  23. Brittney House says:

    I like those Hershey’s sundae pies you can by from the store.

  24. beth shepherd says:

    Peanut butter pie is my favorite.

  25. Cynthia W says:

    My favorite is Key Lime Pie. Though Sweet Potato Pie is a close 2nd!

  26. PEANUT BUTTER CUP ICE CREAM PIE, I made this and couldn’t stop eating. So good, and thank you. I test things with the family before springing it at dinners for family or friend or both.

  27. My favorite is chocolate silk pie.

  28. One of my favorites is Buttermilk Pie. My recipe is in a cookbook with an Andy Griffith Show theme.

  29. Oh my favorite pie is banana cream pie! Your pie looks so good!

  30. Karen Drake says:

    My favorite pie is Chocolate Cheese Pie.

  31. Have to go with key lime pie as my all-time favorite, but no pie is a bad pie!! 🙂

  32. joe gersch says:

    I like chocolate mousse pie

  33. My favorite kind of pie is pumpkin. I made it a few times by following the recipe on the can but I have better luck buying it already made.

  34. Rosanne Morrison says:

    I like Cherry Pie the best. Do not have a recipe or it. I buy it at the store. The last time I tried to make one my husband called it “cherry soup”

  35. This looks so yummy I pinned it. My favorite pie is cherry

  36. Susan Smith says:

    My favorite kind of pie is chocolate cream pie.

  37. My favorite pie is banana cream.

  38. My favorite pie is pumpkin with whipped cream.

  39. my favorite kind of pie is coconut cream.

  40. Keeley Sullivan says:

    WOW I love a lot of different pies. Apple, strawberry, chocolate, lemon…. way to many to choose.

  41. Barbara Fox says:

    My favorite pie is apple pie…with a cup of coffee. YUM!!!!

  42. My favorite pie is pecan but cherry and peanut butter pies are close behind.

  43. denise turner says:

    My favorite pie is Key Lime Pie

  44. Peggy Rydzewski says:

    I cn not walk away from a lemon mergerine. so yummy.

  45. Lori Taube says:

    Hands down, my favorite pie is apple! My recipe is a secret though. 🙂

  46. Lorena Keech says:

    Picking a favorite is hard, cuz we love our pie. If we had to pick one, it would probably be strawberry rhubarb.

  47. Laurie Emerson says:

    My favorite kind of pie is Strawberry Rhubarb.

  48. Carolyn Daley says:

    My favorite is peanut butter pie, but our recipe is a bit different. Ours is made with the Oreo crust, cream cheese, peanut butter, cool whip, and hot fudge. I love Reese’s, but we have never added the candy to our pie. I am going to bookmark your recipe because I love ice cream and I bet your version of peanut butter pie tastes better than mine! =)

  49. tina reynolds says:

    I love Lemon Merigue Pie

  50. My husband is obsessed over peanut butter pie. Thank you

  51. I love a banana cream pie with graham cracker crust.

  52. cynthia dawson says:

    I love a really great peach pie!

  53. Nicole C. says:

    My favorite kind of pie is coconut!

  54. Stephanie Galbraith says:

    I love love love cheesecake and I love pumpkin pie! 😀

  55. My fav is chocolate silk!

  56. I love sweet potato pie.

  57. French Silk is my favorite. I don’t have a recipe because I only get it when we go out to eat.

  58. Trisha McKee says:

    I love apple pie! I don’t have a specific recipe for it but in the fall, that is what I love to make.

  59. Thank You for the giveaway…our favorite pie to make is Dutch Apple; we use recipes we find online, or in old cookbooks.

  60. I like caramel pecan pie.

  61. Melanie Comello says:

    My favorite pie is Oreo pie 🙂 Home made, just delicious!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *